That error message should only occur when you run kinit -k without specifying a client principal name on the command line. Since you clearly are specifying a principal name, my best guess is that we introduced an argument parsing bug on Windows when we added getopt_long() support to the Unix build (in commit 8f9ade8ec50cde1176411085294f85ecfb2820a4 on Feb 24 2016). Specifically, I suspect the "optind" variable as seen by kinit is not set correctly after the call to getopt_long(). Unfortunately, I don't currently have the ability to investigate further without spending a lot of time spinning up a Windows development environment.