I believe we can retroactively add compatibility with pre-1.11 ipropx dumps, by trying the 1.11 policy format and then the 1.8 format. We can't retroactively add compatibility in the old-slave direction, but compatibility in that direction is problematic anyway, as there is no easy way to pass a per-slave flag to kdb5_util dump to generate an old-format dump on the master. (With traditional kprop, the admin is responsible for writing a cron job which generates the dump and invokes kprop for each slave, and can generate older-format dumps for older slaves in the job.) Regardless of what we do, we need to document this issue where we talk about upgrades.