| Date: | Fri, 21 Nov 2014 21:37:06 -0700 |
| From: | Shawn M Emery <shawn.emery@oracle.com> |
| To: | krb5-bugs@mit.edu |
| Subject: | kadmind w/interactive master key + full resync = dump failure |
When the master key is provided during kadmind startup and a full resync
is required for a slave, kdb5_util incorrectly assumes that the stash
file or that the password command argument is required to dump the
database for propagation, resulting in error:
# /usr/lib/krb5/kadmind -d -m
Enter KDC database master key:
kadmind: create IPROP svc (PROG=100423, VERS=1)
kadmind: starting...
iprop_get_updates_1: start, last_sno=0
iprop_get_updates_1:
clprinc=`kiprop/XXXXXXXXXXXX'
svcprinc=`XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX'
iprop_get_updates_1: end (FR NEEDED)
iprop_full_resync_1: start
iprop_full_resync_1:
clprinc=`kiprop/XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXx'
svcprinc=`XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX'
iprop_full_resync_1: fork=0 (25264)
iprop_full_resync_1: run `/usr/sbin/kdb5_util dump -i
/var/krb5/slave_datatrans_XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX' ...
iprop_full_resync_1: fork=25264 (25263)
iprop_full_resync_1: end (OK, sno=0)
kdb5_util: Cannot find/read stored master key while reading master key
kdb5_util: Warning: proceeding without master key
iprop_full_resync_1: pclose=256
iprop_full_resync_1: exec `kprop -f
/var/krb5/slave_datatrans_XXXXXXXXXXXXX XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX'
...
kprop: No such file or directory while trying to stat
/var/krb5/slave_datatrans_XXXXXXXXXXXXX.dump_ok
The problem is that kdb5_util makes a false assumption that the dump is not
valid if the master key is not available. This is a false assumption in a
couple of aspects:
1. The master key may not be readily available during automated propagation
if the stash file has not been created. Admins may not want stash files due
to security risks.
2. Having a master key does not necessarily mean that you can validate a db
dump. There is no way to validate the principals' keys even if they
could be
decrypted. The only keys you could verify is the master key.
Suggested fix is to not make the absence of a stash file or a password
command argument non-fatal:
src/kadmin/dbutil/kdb5_util.c:
@@ -476,11 +476,17 @@
global_params.stash_file,
&master_kvno,
0, &master_keyblock))) {
com_err(progname, retval, _("while reading master key"));
com_err(progname, 0, _("Warning: proceeding without master key"));
- exit_status++;
+ /*
+ * We don't want to count as an error if for instance the stash
+ * file is not present and we are trying to automate propagation,
+ * which really doesn't need a master key to do so.
+ */
+ if (retval != KRB5_KDB_CANTREAD_STORED)
+ exit_status++;
return(0);
}
}
if ((retval = krb5_db_fetch_mkey_list(util_context, master_princ,
Shawn.
--